(评论)
(comments)

原始链接: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44015614

Hacker News 上的一个讨论帖关注 Gnosis Evolve MCP,这是 kordless 为 Claude Desktop 开发的一个工具,允许它构建和组合其他工具。用户 joshstrange 表达了兴奋之情,因为它反映了他之前设想的一个概念。rezapped 提出了一些关键问题:可能的递归和抽象的深度,合适的安全防护措施(沙盒 vs.人工审核),细粒度小工具相对于 AutoGPT 等单体智能体的优势,以及“Sovereign v1.1”许可证在 AI 生成工具背景下的含义。他还思考这个工具是否会成为个人自动化的福音,或者成为恶意软件创建的潜在途径,并征求 Hacker News 社区的意见。简单的 Python 插件结构和清单被认为比复杂的智能体更容易审核。

相关文章
  • Claude 桌面版 Gnosis Evolve MCP 2025-05-17
  • (评论) 2025-05-10
  • (评论) 2025-05-14
  • 2025-05-17
  • (评论) 2025-05-16

  • 原文
    Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
    Gnosis Evolve MCP for Claude Desktop (github.com/kordless)
    18 points by kordlessagain 1 day ago | hide | past | favorite | 2 comments










    I was just talking about this 3 days ago [0], so cool to see an example of what I was imagining. I look forward to testing this out.

    [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43989110



    That’s got me wondering:

    How deep can the recursion go? Could Claude use Evolve to build a meta‑tool that composes other tools, gradually ratcheting up abstraction like a miniature AutoCAD for software?

    What’s the right blast‑radius guardrail? The README flags a security doc, but in practice do we need sandboxed micro‑VMs à la Firecracker, or is human‑in‑the‑loop code review still feasible once the tool chain snowballs?

    Does tiny‑tool granularity beat monolithic “agents”? Each plugin is just a plain Python function with a manifest—feels easier to audit/reason about than the sprawling state machines we see in AutoGPT land.

    License experiment: It’s under the “Sovereign v1.1” license—free for individuals, paid for corp use. If recursive self‑programming catches on, does this model become a new norm for AI‑generated utilities?

    I’m stoked about the possibility that my assistant could one‑click evolve from “helpful code reviewer” to “on‑device tool‑smith,” but equally terrified that I’ll wake up to a laptop that’s spent the night for‑looping rm -rf. Curious what the HN hive‑mind thinks: stepping stone to personal automation nirvana, or a future malware authoring kit?







    Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact



    Search:
    联系我们 contact @ memedata.com