布拉格机场警方被迫关闭面部识别摄像头。
Czech police forced to turn off facial recognition cameras at the Prague airport

原始链接: https://edri.org/our-work/czech-police-forced-to-turn-off-facial-recognition-cameras-at-the-prague-airport-thanks-to-the-ai-act/

2018年至2025年,捷克警方在布拉格瓦茨拉夫·哈维尔机场运行人脸识别系统,引发批评并最终被裁定为非法。该系统将旅客的“生物指标”与通缉/失踪人员数据库进行比对,在没有捷克法律要求的明确法律依据以及欧盟人工智能法案后来规定的司法批准的情况下运行。 数字权利组织IuRe于2021年向捷克数据保护局(DPA)提出投诉,该局在近四年后确认了对数据保护立法的违规行为。尽管有警告和媒体关注,该系统在欧盟人工智能法案的生物识别监控条款全面生效之前仍继续运行。 DPA还指出了警方“数字个人图像信息系统”存在的问题,该数据库包含2000万张照片,用于追溯身份识别,引发了人们对潜在滥用用于监控抗议者的担忧。IuRe倡导更明确的法律指导方针和对生物识别数据处理的公众监督,强调系统性地无视法律保障,并敦促新任内政部长审查现行立法。

## 布拉格机场人脸识别系统关闭 由于隐私问题,捷克警方被迫关闭了布拉格机场的人脸识别摄像头。Hacker News上的讨论显示,公众对这项技术存在分歧。 一些人认为,在出入境点自动识别潜在罪犯的系统很有价值,尤其是在考虑到政府历史上过度干预的情况下,并建议互惠互利,例如更高效的安全检查。另一些人则表达了对政府监控和潜在滥用的深刻不信任,强调了隐私权的重要性。担忧还延伸到技术本身,包括误识别的风险以及控制这些系统和数据的私营公司所扮演的角色。 许多评论员指出,通过手机、信用卡和机场安检程序已经存在普遍的追踪,这已经侵犯了隐私,质疑增加人脸识别的意义。另一些人强调需要严格的监督和问责制以防止滥用,而有些人则认为专注于真正的威胁,例如加强驾驶舱门的安全,比“安全秀”更有效。
相关文章

原文

Airport facial recognition system long criticised

The Czech Republic Police used a camera system with facial recognition capabilities at Václav Havel Airport in Prague from 2018, until it was shut down in August 2025. The system enabled real-time recognition of the faces of people passing through the airport. Their so-called bio-indexes, or, simply put, facial contours converted into numbers, were compared with a database of wanted or missing persons.

EDRi member IuRe drew attention to the situation back in 2021. At the time, IuRe lawyers argued that the processing of biometric data in Czechia is only possible on the basis of explicit permission granted by a special law. IuRe ultimately filed a complaint with the Czech Data Protection Authority (DPA), requesting an investigation. The result of the inspection, which IuRe requested in the summer of 2025 under the Freedom of Information Act, confirmed the suspicion of a violation of personal data protection legislation.

Biometric surveillance ended thanks to the AI Act

Criticism of the facial recognition system only increased after the AI Act came into force because the law explicitly requires judicial approval for each use of such a system, which wasn’t provided for the airport.

Therefore, since the specific portion of the AI Act related to biometric surveillance came into force in February 2025, till the airport facial recognition systém was shut down in August 2025, the police’s use of this system was illegal. It was in operation despite the fact that the police had been repeatedly warned of its illegality and the media had also taken an interest in the matter.

Set clear boundaries for the police

The inspection by the Czech DPA took almost four years. During that time, no effective action was taken. However, the results are clear: police need to be given clear guidelines for processing biometric data, which should be enshrined in laws approved by elected representatives of the people and thus subject to public scrutiny. The current situation, apart from violating European legislation, creates a fertile ground for various forms of abuse of these technologies.

The police systematically violate laws when processing biometric data

The Czech police are also ignoring the law in the case of another biometric tool – Digital Personal Image Information System. This was also pointed out by IuRe and subsequently by the Czech DPA. The system works with a reference database of approximately 20 million photographs of all persons who have been issued identity cards or passports, and compares them with photographs of persons of unknown identity.

This makes it possible to trace their probable identity retrospectively. According to the police, the system is used, for example, to identify the deceased. However, the same system can also be concievably used to identify people participating in demonstrations.

The obvious systemic problems with the use of facial recognition tools by the police should therefore be a matter of concern for the new Czech Minister of the Interior, who should initiate a review of the legislation. The current national legislation does not comply with the European directive in terms of legal safeguards for the processing of biometric data.

IuRe will continue to monitor biometric surveillance in Czechia, thanks in part to financial support from the public received through their informational website about biometric surveillance called Czechia is not China. The website was created with the support of EDRi and was linked to a crowdfunding campaign.

Contribution by: EDRi member, Iuridicum Remedium (IuRe)

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com