一些小说家正在成为游戏编剧,反之亦然。
Some novelists are becoming video game writers – and vice-versa

原始链接: https://www.theguardian.com/games/2025/apr/30/novelists-video-game-writers

游戏编剧和小说家之间的界限越来越模糊,这既源于现实的经济压力,也源于创作上的相互满足。小说写作难以维持生计,而游戏写作则因裁员等问题而显得不稳定。一些作家,例如哈里·约瑟芬·吉尔斯和乔恩·英戈尔德,发现这两种形式互相启发,甚至在同一个世界观下创作游戏和小说。 游戏和小说写作的关键区别在于创作过程、受众参与和文化认知。小说写作更独立自主,而游戏写作则需要大量的协作。游戏编剧必须迎合不同玩家的动机,而小说家对人物动机的掌控则更多。书籍的文化地位使其获得比游戏更高的认可度,也导致游戏创作人员的社会地位相对较低,不过一些人认为这反而是一个尝试创新、开辟新道路的机会。最终,游戏行业的灵活性和相对年轻的特性更有利于创新。

一篇关于小说家转向游戏写作的Hacker News讨论文章,引发了人们对该领域独特挑战和机遇的关注。评论者们就游戏与书籍的文化地位展开了辩论,一些人认为过于注重高雅地位会阻碍创造力。一些用户提到了体现优秀写作的特定作者和游戏,例如雷蒙德·E·费斯特的《克隆多尔的背叛》和彼得·瓦茨的作品。讨论深入探讨了游戏叙事的重要性,对于剧情驱动型游戏是否具有足够的重玩价值,意见不一。一些人欣赏沉浸式叙事和角色塑造,而另一些人则优先考虑游戏性,并认为故事情节会造成干扰。讨论中也有一些关于游戏行业经济吸引力的见解。总的来说,这场讨论反映了一个复杂且不断发展的景象:文学人才越来越多地在互动式电子游戏世界中找到了自己的位置。
相关文章
  • 时间作祟 2025-04-25
  • (评论) 2024-01-22
  • (评论) 2024-01-01
  • (评论) 2024-05-09
  • (评论) 2024-02-11

  • 原文

    I’ve been working in games for a little more than 15 years, and the main thing I’d say about it at this point is that it’s a pretty annoying job to explain at parties. People often say something like, “Oh, I don’t really play games,” which is surely an odd thing to tell a game designer moments after you’ve been introduced; I don’t really eat croissants, but that’s not the first thing I bring up if I meet a patissier.

    So one of the joys of publishing my first novel last year was the option to sidestep all of that, and say: “Oh, I’m a writer.” I wrote a novel; I’m working on another one; job done, the conversation can move on. Nobody says, “Oh, I don’t really read books,” even though that’s at least as likely to be true.

    It’s become clear to me that I’m not alone in switching between the two media. Why is this? Well, for a lot of people, it’s the money. Writing novels is a notoriously difficult way to make a living, and novelists have always wrangled together careers out of whatever’s going. A 2022 report commissioned by the Authors’ Licensing and Collecting Society (ALCS), found that professional authors are paid a median of £7,000 a year from their writing. Mallory Marlowe is a romance writer – her debut Love and Other Conspiracies made the USA Bestseller list last year – and her day job writing for video games is part of what makes that possible. “Thankfully, I have a consistent paycheck coming in,” she says, “which is an advantage because the payment structures in publishing aren’t exactly sustainable.”

    At the same time, game writers are also having a rough time of it – GDC’s 2025 State of the Games Industry report claimed that one in five narrative designers and writers had been laid off in the previous year. So of course some game writers are looking for opportunities elsewhere.

    Scots sci-fi … Raik. Photograph: Harry Josephine Giles

    Sometimes, writers even find the forms feed into each other, with a direct relationship between the two. Harry Josephine Giles’ game Raik, written in Scots and English, feels like a precursor to her book Deep Wheel Orcadia, a verse novel written in the Orkney dialect that won the 2022 Arthur C Clarke award. And Jon Ingold, co-founder of narrative game studio Inkle (80 Days, Expelled!), released two novels set in the world of the studio’s game Heaven’s Vault, with a third to come in May. Inkle published the books themselves; for Ingold, writing them was a way to spend more time in the world of the game, although, he says, “the plot in the novel was harder to construct. In a book, the protagonist needs focused motivation, all the time, or they stop doing things. But in a game, a player will investigate simply because the world exists”.

    When I ask all the novelist-game writers I know what the biggest difference between the forms is for them, I’m surprised by how different the answers are. For some, it’s a matter of process – novels can act as a release from the compromises of collaboration, while games can provide a break from sitting in a room on your own. Joe Dunthorne (Submarine, The Adulterants) has written novels, poetry and most recently a memoir (Children of Radium), and a few years ago he did a huge amount of work on a big-budget video game that got cancelled without ever being publicly announced. Even though the game didn’t work out, he says that, “after the loneliness and madness of novel-writing, I was relieved to go to an office every day. I loved working with games designers, in particular. I was in awe of their ability to think through these dizzyingly complex structures.”

    Post-apocalypse mystery … Saltsea Chronicles. Photograph: Die Gute Fabrik

    Sharna Jackson has written children’s novels including High-Rise Mystery and The Nine Night Mystery. She also worked on Die Gute Fabrik’s post-apocalypse mystery game Saltsea Chronicles and an audio experience for Yoto. For her, the key difference is that with most games, you’ll write “many, many words that may never be read or heard – it all depends on the pathways your players take through the experience”. Some of your best work may end up in the “rare outcomes and Easter eggs” that only a few players will encounter. Mallory Marlowe, meanwhile, talks about how novels offer, “a strange amount of independence” to writers used to working in games, while novelists might take a while to get used to creating game stories that work for players with wildly varying degrees of investment in the writing. “Some people just want to press buttons and cause trouble,” she says. “Others are going to engage with everything on a story level”.

    Sooner or later, almost everyone I talk to brings up the radically different cultural status of games and books – their equivalent of my complaint about people at parties. Jim Munroe (We Are Raccoons, Unmanned) has been writing games and books for more than 25 years, and he talks about how books are culturally valued in a way games aren’t. “Creators are in games in spite of the low status of games,” he says. Naomi Alderman, author of Disobedience and The Future, echoes some of this experience. There was a week in which both her novel The Power and her game Zombies, Run! (co-created with Six to Start) won awards. The award for her book made the papers, even the front page of the Times of India, while the Zombies, Run! award barely made the specialist games press.

    skip past newsletter promotion
    Author Naomi Alderman wins the 2017 Bailey’s women’s prize for fiction for her novel The Power. Photograph: Stuart C Wilson/Getty Images

    But although everyone talks about the different position that games have in the wider world, not everyone responds to it with my slightly ungenerous irritation. Munroe says that it means games tend to draw creators with a more independent streak. Marlowe enjoys the way that people are intrigued and confused by the idea of game writing, and relishes the follow-up conversations. And for Harry Josephine Giles, the position that games occupy is part of what makes them joyful. She points out that games are still young compared with the novel, their conventions less fixed. Early English novelists like Aphra Behn and Laurence Sterne could mess around more, print a page entirely black, push at the still-forming edges of what a novel was. Nowadays only the most experimental novels have that freedom, “ossified” by their place in culture. Games – newer and with a lower cultural status – remain malleable. Plus, as Dunthorne says, “writing often comes pretty far down the list of priorities in game design – and that’s OK. Games are not novels.”

    Clearly, the emerging generation of young writers grew up as native video game players, so they’re willing and able to switch between the two cultural forms without finding it weird, and without seeing one as necessarily “better” than the other. And sure, if you work in games, there are still people at parties who will say: ”Oh, I don’t really play those.” But sometimes that might mean you get to make something weirder and more surprising, while nobody’s looking.

    联系我们 contact @ memedata.com