美国国防部长绕过官方通讯设备
How the US defense secretary circumvents official DoD communications equipment

原始链接: https://www.electrospaces.net/2025/04/how-us-defense-secretary-hegseth.html

国防部长皮特·希格塞斯绕过五角大楼的安全协议,在他的办公室安装了一台带有直连互联网线路的私人电脑,以便使用Signal通讯软件。据报道,这样做是为了方便与偏好使用该应用的特朗普政府官员进行沟通,同时也因为五角大楼内部的手机信号较差。 尽管可以使用安全的政府通信网络以及专门的国防部长电缆通信中心(该中心提供跨多个平台和级别的全面语音、视频和数据功能),希格塞斯仍然坚持使用Signal。他的个人电脑安装了Signal,可能还安装了短信程序。 这一行为引发了安全担忧,因为直连互联网线路绕过了五角大楼的安全措施,其监控程度低于NIPRNet等安全网络。五角大楼的一些其他员工也使用直连公共互联网的线路,例如当他们不想被分配给五角大楼的IP地址识别时。这是有风险的,因为此类线路的监控程度不如NIPRNet,后者允许有限地访问外部互联网。

这篇 Hacker News 帖子讨论了美国国防部长使用 Signal 进行官方通讯,绕过安全可靠的国防部系统所引发的担忧。评论者们强调了几项安全风险,包括个人设备容易被黑客攻击以及加密信息可能被长期窃取的可能性。使用个人设备还会引发信息安全问题,例如其他应用程序访问剪贴板,以及不遵守政府的记录保存法律。虽然 Signal 的加密被认为很强大,但问题的关键在于其使用环境:与政府系统不同,它缺乏处理机密信息所需的严格访问控制和监控。文章将此与前任政府处理敏感信息的方式进行了比较,一些人认为现任政府对其无视安全协议的行为尤为恶劣。根本问题在于可用性和安全性之间的平衡,以及绕过官方渠道的潜在动机,无论是出于便利性还是故意逃避问责。一些人建议国防部创建安全易用的替代方案,以防止领导人使用可能有风险的私人渠道。

原文

US defense secretary Pete Hegseth appears to have a private computer in his office that is linked to the public internet. He wanted this computer to use the messaging app Signal, which is the preferred method of communication among Trump's government officials.

Here I will look at the secretary of defense's official communications equipment and the SecDef Cables communications center. There's also a photo in which Hegseth's private computer can be recognized.

US defense secretary Pete Hegseth in his office in the Pentagon, January 30, 2025
(Still from a video message on X, formerly Twitter)

Hegseth's government equipment

Like his predecessors, Trump's defense secretary Pete Hegseth has access to a range of secure and non-secure telephone and computer networks. The equipment is installed at a table behind his back, when sitting at his big writing desk in the Pentagon.

In the photo above we can see that equipment in a set-up that has basically been unchanged since Chuck Hagel, who was Obama's secretary of Defense from 2013 to 2015. In the photo of Pete Hegseth we see from left to right:

- On top of a wooden stand sits a Cisco IP Phone 8851 with a 14-key expansion module. This phone is part of the Crisis Management System (CMS), which connects the President, the National Security Council, Cabinet members, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, intelligence agency watch centers, and others. Its bright yellow bezel indicates that it can be used for conversations up to Top Secret/Sensitive Compartmented Information (TS/SCI).

- Below the CMS phone on the wooden stand is (hardly visible) an Integrated Services Telephone-2 (IST-2), which can be used for both secure and non-secure phone calls. This phone belongs to the Defense Red Switch Network (DRSN), also known as the Multilevel Secure Voice service, which connects the White House, all military command centers, intelligence agencies, government departments and NATO allies.

- Right in front of the IST-2 is another Cisco IP Phone 8851 with a 14-key expansion module, but this time with a green bezel, which indicates that it's for unclassified phone calls. This phone is part of the internal telephone network of the Pentagon and replaced an Avaya Lucent 6424 executive phone.


A better view of these phones is provided by the following photo from 2021:

Former secretary of defense Lloyd Austin in his Pentagon office in 2021,
with a Cisco IP phone with yellow bezel for the CMS and
an IST-2 phone with many red buttons for the DRSN.
(DoD photo - click to enlarge)

- Besides the telephones there are two computer screens, both with a bright green wallpaper, which again indicates that they are connected to an unclassified network, most likely NIPRNet. In the photo of Lloyd Austin's office we see that there's also a KVM switch which is used to switch securely to the SIPRNet (Secret) and JWICS (Top Secret/SCI) networks, using the same keyboard, video and mouse set.

- Finally, at the right side of the table there are two Cisco Webex DX80 videoteleconferencing screens. The one at the right has a yellow label, which indicates that it's approved for Top Secret/SCI and most likely belongs to the Secure Video Teleconferencing System (SVTS), which is part of the aforementioned Crisis Management System (CMS). The other screen might then be for videoconferences at a lower classification level.


Hegseth's personal computer

Despite the wide range of options for communicating via the proper and secure government channels, secretary Hegseth insisted on using Signal. Apparently it wasn't allowed or possible to install this app on one of the government computers, nor on a smartphone that is approved for classified conversations.

Therefore, Hegseth initially went to the back area of his office where he could access Wi-Fi to use Signal, according to AP News. It's not clear whether he used a private laptop or his personal smartphone, both of which would have been strictly forbidden to use in secure areas like this.


Somewhat later, Hegseth requested an internet connection to his desk where he could use a computer of his own. This line connects directly to the public internet and bypassed the Pentagon's security protocols. This new computer must be the one that can be seen in the photo below, as it wasn't there yet on February 21 and has no labels that indicate its classification level:
US defense secretary with a new desktop computer on his desk, March 20, 2025
(DoD photo, see also this video message on X)

Some other employees at the Pentagon also use direct lines to the public internet, for example when they don't want to be recognized by an IP address assigned to the Pentagon. That's risky because such a line is less well monitored than NIPRNet, which allows limited access to the outside internet.

At his new desktop computer, Hegseth had Signal installed, which means he effectively 'cloned' the Signal app that is on his personal smartphone. He also had interest in the installation of a program to send conventional text messages from this personal computer, according to some press sources.

The move was intended to circumvent a lack of cellphone service in much of the Pentagon and enable easier communication with the White House and other Trump officials who are using the Signal app.

SecDef Cables

It is remarkable to what great lengths Hegseth went to use the Signal app, because as defense secretary he has his own communications center which is specialized in keeping him in contact with anyone he wants. This center is commonly called SecDef Cables and is part of Secretary of Defense Communications (SDC) unit.

SecDef Cables provides operational information management and functions as a command and control support center. It is staffed by 26 service members and 4 civilians. They provide "comprehensive voice, video, and data capabilities to the secretary and his immediate staff, regardless of their location, across multiple platforms and classifications."

Furthermore, SecDef Cables serves as a liaison to the National Military Command Center (NMCC), the White House Situation Room, the State Department Operations Center and similar communication centers. Finally, Cables provides the connections for the Defense Telephone Link (DTL), which is a lower-level hotline with military counterparts in about 25 countries, including Russia and China.


Secretary of Defense Communications recruitment video from 2023

Links and sources
- emptywheel: Whiskey Pete’s Dirty Desktop (April 25, 2025)
- AP News: Hegseth had an unsecured internet line set up in his office to connect to Signal, AP sources say (April 24, 2025)
- The Washington Post: Hegseth had Signal messaging app installed on an office computer (April 24, 2025)

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com