GrapheneOS 声称 Google 现在正在与之交战,可能锁定 Pixel 引导加载程序
GrapheneOS claims Google is now waging war against it, could lock Pixel bootload

原始链接: https://www.androidauthority.com/grapheneos-team-google-pressure-3737525/

GrapheneOS 团队指控 Google 联系了 Android OEM 厂商,就其与 GrapheneOS 的合作向他们施压,并威胁使用 Google Mobile Services 授权条款。他们声称 Google 可能会锁定 Pixel 引导加载器、推进 Play Integrity,并使 Android 分支不可行,且希望与美国官员讨论反垄断担忧。尽管赞扬了支持 GrapheneOS 的 Google 工程师,他们表示 Google 的业务部门正试图消灭替代方案。GrapheneOS 此前与 Motorola 合作,并计划推出 Motorola Signature 27 GrapheneOS 版本。这些指控是在围绕 Google OEM 协议的过往法庭诉讼之后提出的。Google 和 Motorola 已被联系征求意见。

Hacker News 讨论了 Android Authority 的报道:GrapheneOS 称 Google 正在与之对抗,并可能锁定 Pixel 引导加载器。评论者抱怨 Google 在 Pixel 依赖 Android 爱好者的情况下 undermining 他们,并称赞 GrapheneOS 提供比 Pixel 原生 Android 更干净、更安全、更注重隐私的体验。一些人将 Google 的敌意归因于广告和 Play 收入,预测 GrapheneOS 最终可能被扼杀。另一些人指出设备支持有限——主要为 Pixel 10a/10 Pro 或昂贵的 Motorola 机型——Pixel 11 不受支持。建议包括扩展到非 Pixel 设备或推出更轻量的版本。一名评论者更喜欢 iPhone 的可预测行为;另一名建议使用 AI 和逆向工程绕过锁定硬件。总体而言,用户批评 Google 锁定 AOSP 和引导加载器,同时称赞 GrapheneOS。
相关文章

原文
grapheneos boot animation

Calvin Wankhede / Android Authority

Add Android Authority on Google:

TL;DR

  • The GrapheneOS team has claimed that Google was trying to harm the project and wipe it out.
  • Google was allegedly contacting Android OEMs to ask whether they were working with GrapheneOS, and was purportedly threatening these brands.
  • The team also suggested that Google could start locking the bootloader on Pixels and taking other actions to make Android forks unviable.

GrapheneOS is the leading Android fork if you want a secure and private smartphone experience. Pixels were the only officially supported platform, but the team is also working with Motorola to launch a Motorola Signature 27 phone with GrapheneOS. However, the developers of this software have now made some interesting claims against Google.

The GrapheneOS team claimed on X that Google was contacting Android OEMs to ask whether them whether they were working with the GrapheneOS project. Furthermore, the team asserts that Google was threatening these brands by citing Google Mobile Services licensing terms.

The group also suggested that Google might eventually institute a variety of measures to thwart GrapheneOS and other Android forks:

We expect Google will begin bootloader locking Pixels, continue heavily pushing the illegal Play Integrity API and trying to make forks of AOSP non-viable. Many of their actions are clear violation of US criminal law. US antitrust law even includes prison time for individuals.

GrapheneOS leadership even said they wanted to talk to US attorney-general Todd Blanche and others in a bid to stop “Google’s escalating anti-competitive behavior.” In saying so, the team also praised Google’s engineers for directly working with the project.

“There are a lot of engineers at Google who support what we’re building and have directly worked with us,” it explained. “People there have repeatedly helped us and even explicitly added support for GrapheneOS to Google software including supporting Vanadium for Play services FIDO2 and passkeys.”

Unfortunately, the team says Google’s business division was the problem rather than its engineers:

Google’s business side is actively trying to wipe out alternatives. Google Mobile Services licensing has many illegal terms aimed at preventing competition. That isn’t enough for them. They’re very directly trying to harm GrapheneOS in multiple ways and outright wipe it out.

Either way, you won’t need to buy a Pixel phone if you’d like to use GrapheneOS. The project formed a partnership with Motorola last year, and the Signature 27 will be available as a GrapheneOS variant. Nevertheless, it would be very concerning if Google were pressuring OEMs to stop working with GrapheneOS. This apparent pressure would also come years after Google lost court battles over its agreements with OEMs. These previous agreements included terms restricting manufacturers when it came to shipping devices with Android forks.

We’ve contacted Google and Motorola for comment regarding these GrapheneOS claims. We’ll update our article as soon as the companies issue a response to us.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com