纽约时报认为批评他们的报道不公平
NY Times Thinks It's Unfair To Criticize Their Reporting

原始链接: https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/ny-times-thinks-its-unfair-criticize-their-reporting

《纽约时报》因一篇报道面临批评,称伊朗水坝可能服务于导弹计划,但缺乏确凿证据;批评者表示这可能为攻击民用水利基础设施提供理由,呼应了伊拉克大规模杀伤性武器宣传。《纽约时报》为其报道辩护。一个历史对照指出,北约在2011年基于未经证实的军用用途说法轰炸了利比亚水利基础设施,造成持久平民伤害。作者的辩护承认没有确凿证据,但称仍存在严重疑问。

相关文章

原文

There's been an avalanche of pushback and a real pile-on (much deserved) against the New York Times in the wake of its story published this week entitled: War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason.

The NY Times report is being widely seen as seeking to manufacture a justification for potential future US attacks on Iran's water and electricity infrastructure, given it presents them as serving a military purpose - and not as vital civilian infrastructure simply for providing water to the nation.

This episode has reminded readers of the notorious Judith Miller days - who in the early 2000's served as the NY Times' mouthpiece and clearing house of pro-war propaganda making the case for Bush-Cheney's invasion of Iraq to overthrow Saddam Hussein. 

As it turns out, there was no WMD to be found in Iraq, and Hussein was never looking for "A-Bomb Parts". This is also the era of the 'Niger Yellow Cake' hoax.

This latest controversial NYT report ultimately suggests that many of Iran's dams may have been built to support the country’s missile program - however it is also filled with internal caveats admitting that there's no definiteive proof of his huge claim, just some correlation and theorizing.

But amid the widespread criticism and picking apart of its reporting on Iran's supposedly 'dual use' dams and water infrastructure, the Times is now just doubling and tripling down, and deflecting. 

One independent pundit and author aptly summarized where things stand, saying: "NYT thinks it’s unfair to criticize their reporting."

But back to that prior disastrous Iraq war example, and for a trip down memory lane...

Image

The New York Times did this with Libya too....

Subsequently during the 2011 US-NATO war to overthrow Gaddafi, Libya's water infrastructure was bombed to smithereends, despite that it was vital for millions of civilians:

In July 2011, NATO bombed Libya’s Brega pipe-manufacturing plant & nearby water pipelines, key components of the Great Man-Made River (GMMR), which supplied ~70% of Libya's freshwater. NATO claimed the plant was used for military storage & rocket launches. 

Was that ever verified? A 2012 UN Commission of Inquiry found no independent proof that the plant was used for military purposes! Millions in Tripoli lost running water for weeks in late 2011, and 15 years later, the aftermath remains severe. Destroying Brega’s specialized machinery crippled the country’s ability to manufacture replacement pipes.

Again, with this latest Iranian 'dual use' dams reporting, the response of the journalists behind the report has basically been to shrug and say: "There is no conclusive evidence, but serious questions remain." 

This is literally the pathetic defense of at least one of the authors behind the report.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com