为什么教育体系崩溃了
Why educational system is broken

原始链接: https://keycybermonk.com/edu

当前教育错误地强调记忆具体技能和事实,而不是大脑发展和学会学习,依赖过时的规模化实践。作者认为大脑通过新奇体验成长,并建议在专门化(如数学)之前提供广泛的早期经历。学校应按教育质量而非学生消费来评判。作者认为父母提供了多样化的童年经历,而非大学,并称赞蒙台梭利。

一个题为“为什么教育体系已崩溃”的Hacker News帖子包含三条评论。一位评论者认为美国教育体系是由洛克菲勒家族塑造的,目的是培养工人而非教授逻辑与推理,并建议以批判性思维作为替代,让学生质疑假设。另一位回复称,约翰·洛克菲勒主要推广的是霍勒斯·曼从普鲁士借鉴的体系。原帖作者同意批判性思维看起来很有用,还教授道德。总体而言,讨论围绕教育的历史影响以及批判性思维的价值展开。
相关文章

原文

Current education system focuses on wrong things, and is subject to traditional practices that were developed due to need of scaling, instead of due to improvement of the system itself.

The core issue is that school is not actually focusing on brain development and "learning how to learn". By the way, this is what I was told as the reason of studying history and all those other subjects I didn't like. Instead it focuses on developing concrete skills in a bunch of different practices, and I will explain why it is completely wrong.

The brain develops when it is exposed to a new experience/task, because first brain is doing the task inefficiently using several existing neural centers, and then in around ~15 minutes it finds a neural center in between of those, and now performs the task much more efficiently.

It needs more studying, but at this point I am pretty sure that to become a genius at math, the best play is to learn everything except math for multiple years, to develop brainpower, and only then to go into math when your brain is ready, and reach the frontier much faster.

Instead the school system does completely opposite - the student can't choose what to study, needs to memorize concrete facts and crevices of systems (the grades measure that instead of measuring how well the student was exposed to various experiences). As provider of education the school should be graded on how well it provides the service of education, instead of users being graded on how well they consume the service.

Big thanks to my parents for letting me not to go to college, and for developing me with lots of different experiences in childhood.

Shoutout to Maria Montessori.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com