纽约市应该仔细测量一棵新树。
New York City should carefully measure a new tree

原始链接: https://blog.willmeye.rs/new-york-city-should-carefully-measure-a-new-tree/

利用纽约市2021年的机载激光雷达数据,以及较早的树木调查和航拍图像,博客作者威尔·梅耶斯找出了一些可能超越“皇后区巨人树”的候选树木。“皇后区巨人树”是纽约市经精确测量确认的最高树,高达133.8英尺。他寻找这些候选树木的灵感来自英伍德山公园里的高大北美鹅掌楸。他还制作了一份互动图表,对比候选树木的高度、树冠、周围林冠和地面海拔。梅耶斯敦促公园管理部门仔细测量这些树木,并考虑加以保护。尤其是据报道,他家附近一些年代久远、体型巨大的树木因坠落树枝造成危险而被移除。他认为,识别并保护值得关注的树木,可以避免它们在意外中被毁掉。尽管他开玩笑说,寻找全市最高的树似乎有点傻,但他坚持认为,这件事有助于防止 notable trees 因意外而消失。

一场 Hacker News 上的讨论赞叹了激光雷达(LiDAR)和现代分析技术如何回答看似不可能的问题,例如寻找纽约市最高的树。发帖者认为,这体现了一种更广泛的能力:调查过去似乎无法回答的问题。 commenters质疑数据集的准确性,并讨论皇后区巨树附近的一棵候选树是否就是同一棵树。另一名 commenter指出,政府扫描通常可以达到亚分米级精度。讨论大多集中在一个问题上:公开 notable 树木的位置,是否会纵容破坏者或盗伐者。尽管这种风险确实存在,commenters提到了现有的“伟大树”名录,并认为对这些树的认可能够激发公众的珍惜之情,而不只是带来伤害。 普罗米修斯——那棵为研究而被砍伐的古狐尾松——以及 Kiidk’yaas——那棵为抗议而被砍伐的金云杉——等例子,凸显了树木过去所遭受的损失。不过,Kiidk’yaas 的克隆树苗仍带来了一线希望:提高公众意识或许能促进树木保护。总体而言,评论者倾向于认为,应当测量并赞美这些树,同时希望公开这些信息能够促使人们加强保护。
相关文章

原文
New York City should carefully measure a new tree – Will Meyers' Blog

New York City's tallest carefully measured tree is the Queens Giant (according to Wikipedia). It was measured at 133.8 feet (40.8 m) tall and a 19-foot (5.8 m) circumference IN 2004! More than 20 years ago. It's time to find some other candidates for the tallest carefully measured tree in New York City.

I started going down this rabbit hole when working on a much larger project around New England (to be announced soon) and when I was taking a walk in Inwood Hill Park. I was just looking up and wondering how tall the tulip trees get in our park. LiDAR was also on my mind as my current project uses a lot of it. LiDAR has allowed for incredible new perspectives on land, terrain, and (in this case) tree canopies.

I've identified a few good candidates that the parks department should go out and maybe carefully measure.

I got the data from New York City's May 2021 airborne LiDAR flight, published by The Nature Conservancy and the University of Vermont as a citywide layer of estimated tree objects, with the raw classified point clouds from NYS GIS. Earlier numbers are from the 2013-14 survey described in Ma et al. (2023). In addition to that, aerial imagery is NYS orthoimagery from summer 2025, and USDA NAIP 2019 for Alley Pond.

Here are the candidates, tallest to shortest:

candidate crownsurrounding canopyground

Feel free to explore this interactive plot of the observed canopies:

drag to turn, two fingers or right-drag to pan, pinch or scroll to zoom

candidate crownsurrounding canopyground133.8 ft (40.8 m)

This isn't a definitive report on the tallest trees in New York City, but more of a suggestion for whoever is in charge of measuring trees in the city to maybe start looking for a new tallest tree.

I live a block away from Inwood Hill Park. A few trees were cut down due to branches falling. They were big tulip trees, probably a few hundred years old. Is it silly to find the tallest tree in NYC? Yeah, it's pretty silly. But would you want the tallest tree to be cut down by accident? I'd like to point out "Hey, that's the tallest tree in the city" if I ever walked past it.

#featured

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com