人工智能让我感到悲伤。
AI Makes Me Sad

原始链接: https://mondobe.com/ai-makes-me-sad

作者对人工智能怀有深切的矛盾心理:尽管有望从中获得经济利益,他却对AI支配初创企业、就业、艺术、写作和网络文化的前景感到绝望。他担心手艺、主导权和创造力会因此丧失,并将AI驱动的软件开发比作查理·卓别林被自己曾热情服务的工厂机器吞噬。 他为这个行业感到悲哀:初创公司可能被几个提示词取代,劳动者主动训练自己以适应被淘汰的命运,而巨额AI投资除了给软件加上聊天机器人按钮之外,几乎没有带来任何看得见的改善。尤其令他不安的是,社交媒体充斥着机器人账号,SEO内容被批量生成,同行们纷纷追逐收入丰厚的AI职业,却从不思考这些工作的意义。 尽管前景黯淡,作者仍在AI的快速演进中看到了希望。他预期, Industry? 行业将经历剧烈阵痛,甚至可能经历泡沫破裂,从而迫使相关机构走向成熟,并找到一种有用且边界清晰的角色。他最终想要的并不是摧毁AI,而是建立一个合乎逻辑、能够保留人类主动权的技术世界。

Hacker News 上一篇关于“AI 让我感到悲伤”的讨论,探讨了人们为何会哀叹自己失去了曾经让软件开发独具特色的手艺、掌控感、创造力以及初创公司的竞争优势。作者 wondered,如果自己出生得更早,是否能拥有更好的机会;他也为软件行业,乃至更广泛的文化,正被廉价、精致但由 AI 批量生成的内容所淹没而感到悲伤。 评论区分化严重。一些开发者认为 AI 带来了解放:它能 eliminating 繁琐工作、加速创意、降低门槛,并帮助人们学习、研究、制作原型,以及进入过去难以涉足的领域。另一些人则描述了亲手编写代码时失去的满足感、工艺感的衰退、结果不可靠、失业、初级岗位招聘危机,以及随着产品越来越容易被复制,软件行业壁垒的瓦解。 不少评论者反对简单地把“编程”和“创造产品”对立起来。他们指出,人们既可以看重工艺,也可以看重最终成果,同时仍然觉得 AI 贬低了创造力或人与人之间的联系。他们认为,创作门槛的降低或许会带来更丰富的成果,但也会让注意力、分发能力、声誉、社群、维护质量和真正对用户产生的影响变得更重要。 讨论中反复出现的结论是:技术本身既非全然有益,也非全然有害。技术带来的收益、就业和权力,取决于教育、领域专长、社会选择,以及 institutions 能否应对 AI 带来的外部影响。
相关文章

原文

October 2nd, 2026

Am I allowed to say that? Because it does.

Maybe it's because I'm writing this at 2:00 AM, which is about the only time I let myself experience sadness for a prolonged period of time, but every time I see a post on Twitter or LinkedIn about a new development in AI, I feel a sense of hopelessness.

And I'm saying this as someone who is absolutely in a position to benefit from AI. If I added a few vibecoded projects to my resume, the gaping maw of every startup, enterprise company, and FAANG behemoth would open to me. Just the other day, I sat near a table of my fellow TAs as they discussed their plans to work at OpenAI after graduation, eyeing $500k salaries.

But I don't want to do that. I don't want to prompt Codex for a living, or Claude for that matter. Maybe it's because I don't even really know what that looks like. As sure as I know anything, I know what it sounds like. It sounds like a loss of craft, a loss of control, a loss of creativity. It sounds like Charlie Chaplin in Modern Times, the scene where he's so enthusiastic about screwing hex nuts in a factory that he screws the buttons on people's shirts, and then he goes and gets himself caught in the conveyor belt, snaking through the gears and screwing in the hex nuts inside the machine. It sounds like people around me are throwing themselves at the machine, volunteering to make themselves obsolete for $500k a year. If you genuinely, genuinely, believed artificial superintelligence was coming, why would you want to work at the company that would be in the best position to replace its employees?

It makes me sad that I missed the boat on startups. I think I could have been a pretty formidable startup founder had I been born five or ten years earlier. I'm good at web stuff, I'm good at Rust, I can even do OS stuff. I watched all the YC Stanford lectures this summer while translating tests from one language to another as an intern. Now there's no such thing as a startup, there are only "AI startups", where you build a company that somebody else can write a prompt for in 30 seconds. And if they can't write a prompt for it now, they'll be able to next year with GPT-7, or whenever AI hardware fabrication gets better.

It makes me sad that AI evangelists are so quick to adopt the language of online incels, and that AI-generated art and music have become the defining aesthetic of fascism in the 2020s while AI-generated writing went from risible to a mark of stupidity to something reluctantly accepted since it sits at the fringes of everything useful on the Internet like a kind of digital mold.

The overwhelming weight of it all feels so stifling. It feels like there's no way to stop it. I can't imagine a Twitter (sorry, an X) where every post isn't filled with verified bots spewing LLM nonsense in the replies. I can't imagine an article about some random topic on some random webpage, designed to maximize SEO for some banner ad I won't see because I block ads, being written by a human. We would have to rebuild all our institutions.

Honestly, though, it doesn't sound that hard to rebuild all our institutions. Twitter is only 20 years old, LinkedIn is only 23. Most of these were in need of a refresh anyway. I don't know much about the Dark Ages, but I know that Muslims and Irish monks kept the candle of knowledge burning while everyone else ran around crusading. In a similar way, I know that there are a lot of people who feel a lot of the same sadness that I do, even if they don't express it as sadness. I like to think even a lot of AI evangelists feel at least a little sad, like Paul Graham, because he's a Lisp man from way back, and programming language fanatics usually care about humans writing programs.

Another point of hope: the technology industry moves at unfathomable speeds, so we'll start to see a way out of our "dark age" within only a few years as our institutions start to mature and improve. In fact, I suspect that AI will have a fixed role in our society before the end of my natural life. Whether that role is a small one or a major one, I'm not sure. But I know I will feel at least a little happier to have some finality about the whole thing.

I think this will require some painful shifts in our industry, but I also think that this will be a satisfying kind of pain, at least for people like me, like the burn you feel when working out. It feels extremely strange to be looking forward to a bubble bursting. It makes me feel like the AI evangelists who look forward to artists filling out McDonald's applications. But I do. It makes me very hopeful. When I imagine that scenario, I can conjure no emotion besides glee. I desperately want to work in an industry that makes sense, even if a lot of people right now would rather work in an industry that sells nothing to nobody for untold sums of money.

I'm sorry. I want to go back to the Twitter thing because I use Twitter a lot. And, seriously, there are so many verified accounts that just post AI-generated replies to popular posts, and we all just ignore them. It's the most insane, Kafkaesque thing. Absolutely nobody likes it. It's an eyesore. And we're supposed to be living in the most powerful age for AI. You're telling me that nobody at SpaceX/Xai/Grok/SuperGrok/whatever can write a classifier to ban these accounts? I can press a button on any post and be given a full explanation by Grok, a button which I've pressed 2 dozen times on accident and never on purpose. You can't run a decision model for $0.0000001 cents whenever someone hits "Post" and realize that a reply makes no sense?

Recently, I've seen a lot of people point out the fact that billions (trillions?) in AI spend has translated to absolutely no benefit for most consumers of everyday apps. Obviously, people who use ChatGPT get the benefit of having their question answered. But in the world where development is getting faster and cheaper, I can't think of a single piece of software I use that has gotten better. Everything is exactly the same, just with a button to ask a chatbot. Somebody has to notice this eventually.

I want an industry that makes sense. Right now, we have (most of) my undergrad classmates' dream industry. They drink constantly [1], skip lectures, scrape by on their homework with AI, complain about classes, grind Leetcode to get internships, and eventually get their diploma. It must feel like walking around in a literal dream, where your footsteps have no weight, like Wile E. Coyote near a ledge. They commiserate with their friends, "That class is so hard. I just asked Chat." I know because I hear them two seats away from me. Now they get to work a job where they commiserate to an coding agent, "this task is so hard. Do this for me." How come they get to look forward to relief while I feel dread? And that just makes me feel selfish. They're only human too. They is how they've been told to navigate life. For some reason, somebody forgot to tell me. I want an industry that makes sense.

I guess I've been talking a lot about sense. It's 4 AM now, so I guess I'm not making a lot of sense myself. If I wake up tomorrow and the president has signed an injunction on all AI inference, including local models, would I be sadder than I was going to sleep? I don't know. Just ignore me. I'm the homeless guy. I have no home in this industry. Codex, make me a home by the time I wake up.


[1] Seriously, if you ever thought Gen Z doesn't drink, look no further than Georgia Tech. I'm in multiple group chats and Discord servers where the subject discussed most often is the date, location, and intensity of the next planned drinking session.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com