LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it has no AI features

原始链接: https://manualdousuario.net/en/libreoffice-download-record-no-ai/

LibreOffice 24.8(8月26日发布)已成为该软件最受欢迎的版本,发布首周下载量即突破一百万次。尽管该版本在排版和写作工具方面有显著改进,但其主要特色却是一个刻意的“非功能”:即不集成生成式人工智能。 文档基金会(TDF)明确了其立场,称“没有人工智能现在也是一项功能”。TDF 并非完全抵制人工智能,而是认为目前的人工智能应用方式违背了其核心原则,即优先考虑用户隐私、数据主权以及摆脱厂商锁定。他们认为,许多竞争对手将人工智能作为推行订阅制和将用户捆绑在专有云基础设施上的理由。 目前,TDF 建议希望使用人工智能的用户通过可选的社区插件来实现,从而保持软件核心默认“无人工智能”。这一策略已被证明是成功的,表明市场对那些优先考虑数据隐私和独立性,而非盲目追随行业潮流将人工智能植入每一款应用程序的软件替代品有着巨大的需求。

LibreOffice 近期宣布其套件将不会内置人工智能功能,随后其每周下载量创下了历史新高。这一消息在 Hacker News 上引发了热烈讨论,人们就此次增长的真正原因以及软件“记录”的本质展开了辩论。 **讨论中的关键点包括:** * **因果关系与相关性:** 许多评论者认为“创纪录”的标题具有误导性。他们指出下载量长期呈上升趋势,因此达到新高在统计学上是必然结果,而非反 AI 立场的直接影响。 * **“AI 代理”理论:** 社区中很大一部分人指出,LibreOffice 正越来越多地被人工智能工具(如 Codex 和 Claude)以“无头模式”(headless)调用,用于处理和格式化文档。这种使用方式可能比用户偏好更能推动下载量的激增。 * **用户情绪:** 该讨论串凸显了用户群的分化。一些用户将缺乏 AI 功能视为主要卖点,理由是“AI 疲劳”以及对专注、注重隐私工具的需求。另一些人则认为 AI 集成不可避免,LibreOffice 应专注于完善自动化 API,而不是完全避开该技术。 * **方法论:** 批评者指出,所谓的“纪录”往往是忽略背景的主观营销策略。
相关文章

原文

LibreOffice 26.8, released on August 26th, became the software’s most popular update. LibreOffice is a free alternative to Microsoft Office that’s been around for nearly two decades. In one week, the installer was downloaded more than 1 million times — not counting updates via Linux distribution repositories.

Someone might say the improvements to the writing system and typography are a hit among NGOs, government agencies, and offices that use LibreOffice. I’m putting my money on a “non-feature,” though: the statement that LibreOffice doesn’t come with generative AI features due to the technology’s (lack of) privacy.

A day after celebrating the download record and the wide media coverage, The Document Foundation (TDF), which manages the software, spelled out its position in a post titled “Yes, no AI is now a feature”.

The article, signed by Italo Vignoli, says TDF “does not reject artificial intelligence out of hand,” but that the technology doesn’t yet meet an exhaustive list of principles to be included by default. Those principles are:

  • User-controlled execution.
  • No content may leave the computer without authorization.
  • No telemetry of any kind.
  • No dependency on a single vendor.
  • No compromises on [file] format.
  • Entirely optional.

For now, TDF recommends community plugins to integrate AI into LibreOffice.

TDF’s distinctive stance “has almost nothing to do with the technology,” the article continues, before taking a jab at rivals that dove headfirst into AI. For the foundation, “an AI assistant justifies a price increase and strengthens the case for keeping all documents within its own infrastructure,” referring to companies that rely on selling subscriptions.

The Document Foundation’s detailed explanation may disappoint anyone who read the announcement at the LibreOffice 26.8 launch as an anti-AI manifesto.

Whatever the reasons, the LibreOffice 26.8 case answers a question I and others have had since 2023: if the whole market now offers AI baked in software of every kind, is there really no room for AI-free alternatives to stand out? Apparently, there is.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com