请不要粘贴 AI 生成的内容。
Don't Paste the AI, please

原始链接: https://dontpastetheai.com/

当有人向你提问时,他们寻求的是你独特的视角、判断和专业知识,而不是来自聊天机器人的通用且未经润色的回复。依赖人工智能生成并直接复制粘贴的回答是适得其反的;接收者很可能也拥有同样的工具,完全可以在几秒钟内自行生成同样的内容。 相反,应将人工智能视为起草伙伴,而非你个人声音的替代品。阅读模型的输出,提取相关要点,并根据你自己的见解进行重写。保持回复简洁;通常,三句深思熟虑的话比一大段人工智能生成的文字更有价值。如果你觉得模型输出的某一部分很有用,可以引用它并解释为什么它很重要。 归根结底,如果你没有什么有意义的内容可以贡献,承认自己没有明确意见,总好过将人工智能生成的内容伪装成你自己的观点。优先考虑你的人为投入,以确保你的沟通保持真实且切实有效。

这篇 Hacker News 帖子讨论了颇具争议的“AI 垃圾内容”(AI-slop)做法——即直接复制粘贴大模型生成的原始文本并用于专业沟通。 批评者认为,直接粘贴 AI 输出通常显得粗鲁且懒惰,将理解的负担转移给了接收者,并表现出缺乏诚意。许多人建议,在处理专业邮件和 Slack 消息时,个人应“用自己的方式书写”,以保持真实性、展现批判性思维并确保个人成长。 相反,一些用户则为这种做法辩护,认为这是提供完整背景、总结复杂问题或克服语言障碍的有效方式。一位辩护者认为,即使 AI 的输出很“枯燥”,也比沟通不足要好。 这场讨论带有一种讽刺意味:许多评论者注意到,该讨论的源网站(dontpastetheai.com)本身似乎也是由 AI 生成的。参与者普遍认为,虽然 AI 是起草或优化语法的强大工具,但它绝不应取代人的责任。共识是,有意义的沟通需要人工监管,而盲目转发 AI 生成的文本通常被视为数字版的“自己去谷歌搜”(LMGTFY)。
相关文章

原文

Prefer another language?

When someone asks you something, they want your answer. Not a wall of unedited ChatGPT output. A short reply from you beats a long one from a model, every time.

What's happening

Someone asked you a real question. You popped it into a chatbot, copied the answer, and sent it back. It felt fast. It felt helpful. And it usually isn't.

The person on the other side has the same tools you do. If they wanted the generic answer, they would have gotten it in four seconds. They asked you because they wanted your take on it... Your context, your taste, your judgement.

The world is filled with people that don't want to read or think about things, don't be one of them.

Try this instead

  1. Use the AI. Really, go for it. It's a great drafting partner. Just read what it gave you, then write your own take on it, don't just be the proxy between it and the answer.
  2. Pull out the bit that actually answers the question. Drop the rest. Three sentences from you is plenty.
  3. If a piece of the model's answer is genuinely useful, quote it and say why. I checked with Claude and this part lines up:" works great.
  4. If you don't have anything to add, it's okay to say so. "No strong opinion here" is a real, helpful reply.

Want to send this to someone?

If someone just dropped a wall of model output in your DMs, Slack, or PR review, you can send them this link. No lecture required.

Click to copy. They'll get the hint.

Want a stronger version?

If you'd rather send someone the version with feelings attached, we've got you covered.

Take me to the angry version →

Not safe for sending to your manager. Probably.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com