Windows 让人人都能成为罗夏墨迹测验的对象。
Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone (2003)

原始链接: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20030825-00/?p=42803

Windows 的历史充满了各种离奇且非本意的争议。作者讲述了 Windows 95 的原始包装上印有一个婴儿的全息图,结果引发了政府投诉,指控该婴儿“裸体”。尽管该婴儿只露出了腰部以上,微软仍被迫更换了全息图,改用一张穿着工装裤的婴儿图片,这使得原始的“裸体”版成了稀有的收藏品。 这种过度审查的趋势在 Windows XP 时期持续存在。该操作系统面临来自用户和政府的各种投诉,他们认为日常图形中存在“淫秽”意象。例如,“红月沙漠”壁纸被误认为是臀部,一个用户图标被指像希特勒,还有一个卡通形象被指控像某种淫秽的身体部位。最终,微软被迫修改了这些资源,这让作者不禁幽默地质疑起其受众和测试人员独特的解读方式及精神状态。这些事件凸显了公众认知的不可预测性,即便是最平庸的设计也可能被误解为带有冒犯性或潜意识信息。

该 Hacker News 讨论帖探讨了微软雷蒙·陈(Raymond Chen)在 2003 年发表的一篇文章。文章探讨了软件中看似无害的图像——例如 Windows XP 的“红月沙漠”壁纸或 Windows 95 的全息图——如何引发用户和政府机构如同解读罗夏墨迹测试一般,对这些图像产生荒谬的淫秽指控。 评论者分享了类似的经历,指出用户往往会将自身的偏见投射到无害的图形上,这导致企业为了规避争议而采取“企业平庸化”策略。讨论随后演变为关于科技行业更广泛的争论,涉及以下内容: * **空想性错视与审查:** 过度敏感的用户如何曲解标准艺术和用户界面元素,有时甚至迫使公司更改设计以避免商业损失。 * **“裸露”争议:** 提及了各种历史案例,包括涅槃乐队(Nirvana)的《Nevermind》专辑封面和 SGI 的“瘦黑客”照片,凸显了组织对人体结构过度反应的长期模式。 * **现代不满:** 许多用户认为,虽然这些历史轶事很幽默,但微软目前对遥测技术、强制登录和“垃圾软件”的关注,代表了用户体验更为严重的倒退。 归根结底,该讨论帖既是对用户偏执心理的批判,也是对企业倾向于将规避冒犯置于保持设计完整性之上的做法的批评。
相关文章

原文

It seems that no matter what you do, somebody will get offended.

Every Windows 95 box has an anti-piracy hologram on the side. The photographer chose his infant son as his model, since the human face is very hard to copy accurately. The baby sits next to a computer, and as you turn the hologram, his arm rises and points at the computer monitor, which bursts into a Windows 95 logo.

How cute. And everybody loves babies.

Until we got a complaint from a government (who shall remain nameless for obvious reasons) that was upset with Windows 95 because it depicted naked children.

“Naked children!?” we all thought to ourselves.

They were complaining about the hologram on the box. The baby wasn’t wearing a shirt. Even though the baby was visible only from the waist up, the offended government assumed that he wasn’t wearing pants either.

We had to produce a new hologram. In the new hologram, the baby is wearing a shirt and overalls. But since this was a rush job, we didn’t have time to do the arm animation.

So if you still have your copy of Windows 95, go look at the hologram. If the baby in your hologram isn’t wearing a shirt, you have a genuine collector’s item. I have seen the “naked baby” hologram but unfortunately my copy of Windows 95 has a clothed baby.

If you hunt around the web, you can find lots of other people who claim to have found subliminal messages in Windows 95. My favorite is the one who claims to have found images in the clouds bitmap. Hey, they’re clouds. They’re Nature’s Rorschach Test.

Windows XP had its own share of complaints. The original wallpaper for Windows XP was Red Moon Desert, until people claimed that Red Moon Desert looked like a pair of buttocks. People also thought that one of the generic people used in the User Accounts control panel people looked like Hitler. And one government claimed the cartoon character in the original Switch Users dialog looked like an obscene body part. We had to change them all. But it makes me wonder about the mental state of our beta testers…

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com