英伟达、微软、Meta 警告称不应对开源权重模型过度监管
Nvidia, Microsoft, Meta warn against overregulating open-weight models

原始链接: https://www.cnbc.com/2026/07/24/nvidia-microsoft-meta-open-weight-ai-models.html

包括英伟达、微软、Meta 和 Palantir 在内的 20 多家科技巨头组成的联盟,已敦促美国政策制定者避免限制“开放权重”人工智能模型。该团体警告称,为了应对月之暗面(Moonshot AI)等中国公司带来的竞争优势而提出的过早监管,将扼杀本土创新,并导致技术领导地位流向海外。 该联名信指出,开放权重模型能够促进竞争并分散权力,而仅依赖专有的“封闭”模型则会造成系统性的安全风险。支持者认为,开放获取对于民主化创新至关重要,并列举了当专有模型因限制性防护措施而失效时,开放权重模型被有效用于防御网络攻击的案例。 尽管包括财政部长斯科特·贝森特在内的政府官员对中国公司可能通过人工智能“蒸馏”技术窃取知识产权表示担忧,但签署方主张采取针对性的法律措施,而非对技术本身实施广泛限制。虽然主要的专有人工智能开发商 OpenAI 和 Anthropic 并未签署该信函,但其领导层均对 AI 访问的民主化表达了广泛支持,并强调建立一个稳健、开放的生态系统是美国取得经济和技术成功的最佳策略。

包括英伟达、微软和 Meta 在内的各大科技公司发表了一封联名信,敦促美国政府避免对“开放权重”(open-weight)人工智能模型进行限制性监管。签署方认为,此类模型对于保持美国技术领先地位和促进创新至关重要。 这封信在 Hacker News 上引发了激烈讨论。持怀疑态度者认为,这些公司(其中许多公司过去一直对开源原则持敌对态度)仅仅是为了保护自身利益而进行企业游说,或者是为了利用开放模型与 OpenAI 和 Anthropic 等闭源竞争对手抗衡。另一些人则指出,“开放权重”这一说法并不准确,因为这些模型缺乏被视为真正“开源”所必需的训练数据集和代码。 批评人士还注意到谷歌和亚马逊等主要参与者的缺席,这表明行业战略出现了分歧。许多用户对此表示愤世嫉俗,认为这封信是科技巨头为了博取政策制定者好感而对开源叙事进行的虚伪利用,而非出于对人工智能技术民主化的真正承诺。总的来说,这场讨论凸显了企业自身利益、国家安全顾虑与开源社区理想之间的深层矛盾。
相关文章

原文

Nvidia, Microsoft, Meta, Palantir and more than 20 other companies released a letter Friday urging policymakers to avoid "premature restrictions" on open-weight artificial intelligence models that would "stifle competition or drive innovation overseas."

Open-weight AI models are available for users to download, modify and run on their own infrastructure, and they have been the subject of fierce debate within the tech sector in recent weeks.

Chinese open-weight models are gaining steam against leading offerings from American companies like OpenAI and Anthropic, which primarily develop proprietary, closed models. Officials and executives have been weighing whether or not to restrict access to Chinese models in the U.S.

Moonshot AI, a Chinese startup, amplified concerns earlier this month after releasing a model called Kimi K3 that outperforms cutting-edge American offerings across some industry benchmarks. U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC on Tuesday that the Trump administration would look into whether Chinese companies were stealing American intellectual property, and stated that the government has "the ability to sanction them because of this theft."

But in the letter on Friday, the group of U.S. tech companies cautioned against any rash actions. They wrote that open-weight models strengthen competition and ensure that the benefits of the technology are "broadly shared rather than concentrated in a few hands."

"Relying solely on closed models is not inherently safe: they can be breached, misused, or fail in ways that outsiders cannot detect," the letter said. "And concentrating advanced AI capabilities behind a small number of closed models compounds that risk."

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella both shared the letter on their personal social media accounts.

Elon Musk, who runs an AI business under his rocket company SpaceX, also applified the letter on social media, writing that it has his "full support" in a post on X. SpaceX did not officially sign the letter.

OpenAI and Anthropic did not sign the letter. Both companies, which are each valued at nearly $1 trillion, are gearing up for potentially massive initial public offerings that could land as soon as this year. Anthropic confidentially filed its prospectus with the Securities and Exchange Commission in June, and OpenAI followed suit days later.

Greg Brockman, OpenAI's president, said Thursday that the company believes in broad access, and that he has not been involved in any conversations with the Trump administration about potentially banning Chinese open-weight models in the U.S.

"I think that, that fundamentally, AI and AI usage is something that is actually very important to democratize," Brockman told reporters during a briefing in New York City. "And so, for me, at a sort of deep level, I think that having more models, more usage, that is a good thing."

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman addressed the letter in a post on X on Friday, writing that he wants the U.S. to win with both open-weight and proprietary models, and that he is "glad to see this."

Earlier this month, the AI company Hugging Face used an open-weight model from the Chinese company Z.ai to contain a cyberattack that rogue OpenAI models carried out. OpenAI disclosed the attack on Tuesday and characterized it as an "unprecedented cyber incident."

CEO of OpenAI Sam Altman speaks with reporters, following meetings on Capitol Hill, in Washington, D.C., U.S., June 3, 2026.

Kylie Cooper | Reuters

Yacine Jernite, head of machine learning at Hugging Face, told CNBC that the company initially tried to use Anthropic's Fable 5 to analyze the attack, but that it didn't work because the model's guardrails couldn't determine that Hugging Face was trying to defend itself.

Jernite said Hugging Face turned to Z.ai's model GLM 5.2, and was able to contain the attack "very quickly using this model." 

White House advisor Michael Kratsios on Wednesday said that China's Moonshot AI developed its Kimi K3 model by distilling Anthropic's technology. Distillation is a term for an AI training method where a smaller, less capable model is built using outputs from an existing, stronger model.

Kratsios wrote in a post on X that legitimate AI distillation plays a vital role in the open innovation ecosystem, but warned that "large-scale, covert industrial distillation aimed at stealing proprietary U.S. technology" is "unacceptable."

In the letter on Friday, the U.S. tech companies said that concerns about unlawful distillation should be addressed through "targeted legal and commercial frameworks" instead of with "sweeping restrictions on techniques that play an important role in AI innovation."

"Our AI leadership will be judged not by one frontier AI model, but by whether the United States builds a strong, open ecosystem that diffuses into every sector," the letter said. "This is essential for creating opportunities for innovation and prosperity across the country."

WATCH: AI is forcing the cyber industry to revisualize how it operates, says TrustedSec’s David Kennedy

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com