想要回你的图片吗?当然可以……那得收5美元!
Want your images back? That'll be $5

原始链接: https://www.lutr.dev/want-your-images-back-sure-that-ll-be-5-dollars

出于怀旧,作者试图从一个废弃的 Photobucket 账户中找回儿时的照片。登录后,他们发现该平台已对用户内容设置了付费墙,要求每月支付 5 美元的订阅费。尽管作者对这种掠夺性的“重拾回忆”策略感到厌恶,但出于对账户内容的好奇,最终还是屈服了。 在不情愿地支付了订阅费后,作者发现账户里空空如也。更糟糕的是,他们后知后觉地意识到,自己忽略了关于交易不可退款的重要脚注。最终,作者不仅钱财尽失,还遭遇了毫无价值的服务。这个故事警示人们,一些公司正利用用户的怀旧心理,通过欺骗性的订阅模式牟取暴利。

Hacker News 上的一则讨论引起了人们对 Photobucket 向用户收取费用以访问其个人存档照片这一行为的愤慨。该帖子题为《想取回你的图片吗?没问题……交 5 美元!》,引发了关于这种“勒索”手段是否可接受,以及是否构成拒付理由的争论。 虽然一些评论者打趣称这个故事本身就值五美元,但其他人则提供了无需付费即可找回数据的实用建议。其中的建议包括利用《通用数据保护条例》(GDPR)中的“访问权”,该条例在法律上要求公司以机器可读的格式向用户提供其个人数据。然而,参与者指出,这些保护措施主要惠及欧盟居民,这使得美国用户在避免此类服务费方面选择较少。该讨论串是对掠夺性数据托管模式的批评,也提醒了人们数据可移植性的重要性。
相关文章

原文

We're in the era of trillion-dollar companies, but that doesn't mean you should leave $5 on the table!

Take, for example, Photobucket. In case you've never heard of it, it is the Imgur-equivalent of ages ago. I was using it as a kid to upload images there and link them on various forums. A nice, simple website that just did its job.

So what's my old pal Photobucket doing now?

Well, recently, I was going through my old accounts and started cleaning them up. Deleting what needs to be deleted, restoring passwords to what was no longer working, things like that1...

And that's how I remembered about Photobucket!

Now, mind you, that was after I'd already found my old Imgur account with hundreds of old (and nostalgic!) screenshots that I then backed up safely. So I was really excited! This Photobucket account must have been... damn... even older! Who knows what remnants of my childhood I'll find there?

And so, I logged in expectantly. Ready to be amazed! Prepared to drop a nostalgia tear! Excited to finally...

Wait, WHAT?!!

Photobucket paywall titled 'Recover Your Account & Reclaim Your Memories', showing payment options and $5/month pricing
You fu...

You shared them. We protected them.

...

AGAINST WHAT?!! Because it sure as hell isn't against corporate greed! More like:

You shared them. We paywalled them. (And you should thank us!)

So I now have to pay for the images I uploaded on a (previously) free service?!! No way, I'm not doing that! Take my images and keep them on your servers until you go bankrupt! I won't endorse such behavior by giving you money.

I'm no fool!

...

But... I mean it's just $5... Surely my childhood memories must be worth more than that, right? And I guess it's kinda nice they didn't delete them... So, okay, I'll give this some thought and...

Photobucket purchase screen showing '$5/month' selected, with '$50/year — Save $10' as the alternative
Oh. My. God.

$5... PER MONTH?!!

So this unassuming claim:

It's time to relive them for just $5.

from the sweet-sweet Photobucket Inc. was missing just a tiny little detail... a footnote... some legalese, as you might say... That it's a MONTHLY SUBSCRIPTION, MAYBE?!!

THE. BLATANT. GREED!

So they're hoping that I'm curious, I pay for this crap, and then forget about my MONTHLY SUBSCRIPTION? Oh no, no, no. That's almost evil. Paywalling my childhood memories in order to trap me into accidentally subscribing to your useless service? Hoping I'd then cancel it after maybe a few years, when I finally notice an odd expense on my card?

NO.

Just no. I won't stand for this. Childhood memories be damned!


SpongeBob SquarePants time card reading '5 Minutes Later...'

Aw man... I really wonder what's in there... I mean it's just a subscription... I pay the $5, I download my images, I cancel the subscription, and I'm outta there. May God be my witness that it wasn't an easy call, that I fought for my dignity!

Ok, let's do this quickly. I want to minimize the pain.

Enter the card details... click on Pay by Card... wait a bit...

Photobucket confirmation email reading 'Thank you for subscribing.'
You're welcome......

And I'm in!

Finally! Really wondering what's in here! Let's take a... look......

Oh... No...

Empty Photobucket dashboard showing 0 images and the prompt 'Start filling your bucket!'
Start... filling... your bucket...

IS IT FREAKING EMPTY?!!

...

I think I hate myself now. I'm such a fool!!! That's what I get for going along with these predatory tactics... Should've known this would happen. I guess I was using a different, even older Photobucket account as a kid, or something.

...

Wait.

Photobucket. You must have known I don't have any images on my account. AND YOU STILL MADE ME PAY?!! Reclaim your memories my ass.

That's it, I'm done.


SpongeBob SquarePants time card reading 'One Hour Later...'
WAIT

I knew I forgot something!

Photobucket cancellation email reading 'Your subscription has been canceled. We're sorry to see you go, but we hope to see you again in the future!'
Are you sorry now? Is that right?

Okay. Now I'm done.


Editor's note

As I was writing and reliving this beautiful experience, I noticed a little footnote on the payments page:

Photobucket fine print reading 'You will be charged $5 per month until cancelled. We have a 48 hour refund policy.'
Emphasis added by me, of course

Did I notice this in time to request the refund? Of course I didn't. Those 5 beautiful dollars are forever gone.

But maybe this helps someone... Yay to the movement against corporate greed!... 🍻

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com