英国政府的低值采购系统纯属浪费时间
The UK Government's Low Value Purchase System Is a Waste of Time

原始链接: https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2026/05/the-uk-governments-low-value-purchase-system-is-a-waste-of-time/

RM6237低值采购系统旨在简化小型企业的政府招标流程,但其中存在一个令人沮丧的官僚障碍:强制性的月度报告要求。即使企业当月零销售,也必须登录系统并完成多重身份验证,以提交一份“零申报”。 一份信息自由请求揭示了这种低效的真实规模。在2025年3月至2026年2月期间,该系统平均每月有超过1300名用户,然而其中约96%至97%的提交内容均为“零申报”。这意味着每月有超过一千家小型企业被迫浪费时间报告零业务。假设每次申报耗时两分钟,这每月总计造成了超过48小时的行政资源浪费。 作者认为,政府部门应当自行追踪支出情况,而不是将负担转嫁给供应商。更糟糕的是,政府商业机构声称他们并未针对RM6237收集用户反馈,这意味着他们既忽视了造成这一困境的根源,也未能衡量自身繁文缛节所带来的影响。

Hacker News 最新 | 过往 | 评论 | 提问 | 展示 | 招聘 | 提交 登录 英国政府的低值采购系统是在浪费时间 (shkspr.mobi) 16 点,由 ColinWright 发布于 43 分钟前 | 隐藏 | 过往 | 收藏 | 2 条评论 | 帮助 toyg 1 分钟前 | 下一条 [–] 他们应该增加一个“暂停账户”的选项。你提交一次零申报,然后挂起,除非有必要,否则永远不必再回来。这看起来很简单。 回复 solenoid0937 1 分钟前 | 上一条 [–] 政府雇员和部门需要绩效激励。而且不是那种离他们的日常工作非常遥远的“投票”机制。 回复 指南 | 常见问题 | 列表 | API | 安全 | 法律 | 申请 YC | 联系 搜索:
相关文章

原文

It can be hard running a small business. If you want to sell to a large organisation like the UK Government, there are forms to fill in, checks to comply with, tenders to bid on, and a hundred other things.

Luckily, there's the RM6237 Low Value Purchase System to make everything better. If a department wants to buy something below a certain threshold, they can contact any of the registered suppliers and just buy it. No complicated paperwork, cheaper prices, win-win!

Except, there's on annoying bit of bureaucracy. Every month I have to tell the Government Commercial Agency what business I've done.

Hello Terence Eden, It’s time to report your management information to the Government Commercial Agency (GCA). If you didn’t do any business, you still need to use this service to let us know. 9 April 2026 is the deadline to report your March 2026 data You need to report for the following commercial agreement(s):-   RM6237 – Low Value Purchase System Report your management information If you don’t think you should be getting this reminder or there is a problem reporting, please email the support team: Regards, GCA MI collection team

Fair enough, I guess. Let them know how many paperclips I've sold to the Ministry of Administrative Affairs.

But there's a wrinkle. What if I've sold nothing? Well, I still have to log on, wait for an MFA code to be send, click through, and report "No Business".

Screenshot with a button to report no business.

I think that's a waste of time. But I wondered how much time it collectively wastes for the nation's small businesses.

So I filed a Freedom of Information request to see how many people have to sign in to let them know they haven't done any business. They replied quickly - although sent the data as a PDF rather than the requested machine-readable format.

Here's how much of a waste of time it is for everyone:

Date Total Returns Nil Return Percent age
Mar-25 768 729 94.9%
Apr-25 902 876 97.1%
May-25 948 923 97.4%
Jun-25 1,322 1,270 96.1%
Jul-25 1,406 1,355 96.4%
Aug-25 1,369 1,326 96.9%
Sep-25 1,416 1,362 96.2%
Oct-25 1,610 1,556 96.6%
Nov-25 1,713 1,654 96.6%
Dec-25 1,645 1,590 96.7%
Jan-26 1,536 1,487 96.8%
Feb-26 1,588 1,531 96.4%

Even if you assume that it only takes 2 minutes to fill in their form, that's over 2 days worth of time being wasted every month.

At best, 59 small businesses reported that they sold something via RM6237. Well over a thousand businesses are clicking on a button which, frankly, ought not to exist. Why isn't the onus on those buying using the system to report what they've spent and who they spent it with?

After clicking the button, I'm always asked to rate my experience using the service. I FoI'd that data as well but was told:

This information is not held. Feedback scores submitted are anonymised and only available as a service-wide view; consequently, we do not capture or hold results specific to RM6237

So the GCA are wasting everyone's time and do not track how annoying it is.

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com