恐惧与脆弱:玻璃妄想及其历史
Fear and Fragility: The Glass Delusion and Its History

原始链接: https://publicdomainreview.org/essay/fear-and-fragility-the-glass-delusion-and-its-history

这段文字探讨了笛卡尔驳斥一个自认为由玻璃构成的人的哲学意义。笛卡尔用这个例子来定义理性思维——将其与“疯狂”的脆弱结论形成对比——但后来的思想家如福柯认为,笛卡尔*利用*这个形象来确立理性的边界本身。福柯认为,对“玻璃人”逻辑的否定是定义有效思想的基础。 德里达提出了一个反驳观点,认为笛卡尔无意中提升了疯子的状态,通过模糊梦境和妄想之间的界限,暗示理性本身可能比“疯狂”更疯狂。 尽管围绕这个形象存在广泛的争论,这段文字强调了一个关键的缺失:没有人彻底研究过*为什么*这种特定的妄想——认为自己由玻璃构成——在历史上出现。尽管这种现象在哲学讨论中扮演着核心角色,但17世纪这一现象的起源和背景仍然未被探索。

一个黑客新闻的讨论强调了历史上的“玻璃妄想症”,这是一种中世纪的综合症,患者认为自己是由玻璃制成的,因此非常脆弱。 这引发了一场关于我们对自身的理解在多大程度上受到当时流行技术的影响的对话。 用户指出,过去对身体的认知反映了同时代的发明——例如,在工业革命期间将大脑比作蒸汽机。 现在,随着计算机占据主导地位,大脑经常被比作计算机,甚至可能是量子计算机。 这场讨论表明,这不一定是一条通往*真理*的道路,而更像是我们当前世界观和技术视角的反映。 它提出了一个问题:未来的技术将如何在未来几个世纪塑造我们对自身的认知。
相关文章

原文

Three centuries later, Foucault argued that Descartes hadn't just excluded the glass man from his rationality — he had employed him. “The man who imagines he is made of glass is not mad”, Foucault writes, “for any sleeper can have this image in a dream; but he is mad if, believing he is made of glass, he thereby concludes that he is fragile, that he is in danger of breaking, that he must touch no object which might be too resistant, that he must in fact remain motionless, and so on.” To declare the glass man’s thinking invalid was to establish, for the first time, what valid thinking looked like: “Madness is expelled, rejected, denounced in its very impossibility from the very interiority of thought itself.” Jacques Derrida would counter that Descartes had actually done the opposite — by admitting that the dreamer is indistinguishable from the madman, Descartes had made the madman’s condition that of rational life: “reason is madder than madness.” Both Foucault and Descartes agreed, implicitly, that the glass man Descartes had tried to discredit had become the hinge on which their debate turned. But neither Cervantes nor Descartes (nor Foucault and Derrida, for that matter) wrote in detail about the historical occasion of the delusion itself. Why glass? Why this material, this century, these sufferers?

联系我们 contact @ memedata.com